The Evolution of Personal Finance: BNPL and South Africa’s Two-Pot Retirement System

Innovations in fintech and retirement planning are making capital more accessible for spending, emergencies, and investing. Two key developments - Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) and South Africa’s two-pot retirement system - offer greater flexibility in managing funds. However, these innovations come with unique risks and rewards, highlighting the importance of careful budgeting and debt management.

Budgeting, Investing, and Debt Management

Effective budgeting, investing, and debt management are the cornerstones of financial success. Budgeting helps manage income and expenses, allowing adjustments to meet financial goals. Investing helps grow wealth and preserve purchasing power over time, while debt - when used wisely - can serve as a useful tool for short-term needs. However, poor debt management can significantly hinder the ability to save and invest for the future.

The Rise of Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)

BNPL programs offer consumers a convenient way to split payments (up to three months), making purchases more accessible without immediate financial strain. These schemes allow customers to buy items now and pay over time, often interest-free. While this payment flexibility is appealing, BNPL carries risks if not properly managed.

On the positive side, BNPL provides interest-free periods, increased purchasing power, and ease of access. However, missed or late payments can lead to fees and damage credit scores, potentially limiting future access to credit. Moreover, the convenience of BNPL may encourage overspending.

HomeChoice International and BNPL Growth

HomeChoice exemplifies the growth of BNPL where the company experienced significant growth in the BNPL market, with Gross Merchant Value (GMV) increasing by 174.1% to R1.5 billion, generating R73 million in fees. BNPL (PayJustNow) has become the company’s fastest-growing product, attracting 1.8 million customers. A 2023 study revealed that 56.5% of BNPL users applied it to online shopping, while 41.1% used it for travel. PayJustNow, another major player, recorded a 105.8% growth rate, with 36.9% of surveyed users opting for the service. The payment system is gaining traction, especially among younger consumers, but it requires careful budgeting to avoid financial strain from excessive debt.

The Two-Pot Retirement System

BNPL is just one form of debt that has recently gained prominence in the South African economy. However, access to debt has always been prevalent, and it is believed that the long-awaited introduction of South Africa’s two-pot retirement system may encourage fund members to seek access to their savings due to debt burdens. This system divides retirement savings into two pots: one for long-term savings and the other for emergency access.

Here’s how it works:

• Savings Pot: Allows for limited emergency withdrawals, subject to taxation.
• Retirement Pot: Reserved for long-term savings, which cannot be accessed until retirement.
• Vested Pot: Contains all funds invested before 1 September 2024.

The system provides flexibility for workers in financial distress, allowing emergency withdrawals. However, concerns remain about its impact on long-term retirement security. Estimated withdrawals for 2024 range between R20 billion and R100 billion, raising questions about the broader impact on savings. The two-pot system’s benefits include flexibility in accessing funds during emergencies. However, significant downsides include tax implications on withdrawals and the risk of depleting retirement savings prematurely.

The South African Reserve Bank's Perspective

In a recent Special Occasional Bulletin of Economic Notes, the South African Reserve Bank explored different scenarios regarding the system's impact, noting that outcomes will depend on how quickly funds are accessed and whether they are used for consumption or debt reduction. The reforms allow employees annual access to the one-third pot for consumption, while the two-thirds pot is designated to enhance retirement savings.

Real-Life Feedback

Feedback from discussions with participants at a roadshow with colleagues from EasyEquities, RISE EasyRetire, and a financial literacy session with Craig Turton, a wealth adviser at PSG Wealth, indicated that while many appreciate the system’s flexibility, concerns over taxation remain. It was recently revealed that withdrawals worth around R103 million were made, adding about R6.7 million in tax revenue to the fiscus from the first withdrawals processed. Organisations like Cosatu have advocated for tax relief, especially for low-income workers.

Some participants shared how they plan to invest their savings pot in assets that generate passive income (e.g., government bonds or property) or in ventures that could benefit them during their employment and retirement, such as livestock. Others prefer to preserve their savings pot for long-term security.

Regarding BNPL, some of my friends and relatives have personally shared how it has helped them manage their finances and acquire items they would otherwise have needed to save for. Some even used the cash they had available after using BNPL to invest through platforms like EasyEquities, which allows investments of any amount.

Making the Most of BNPL, the ‘New Debt,’ and the Two-Pot System

BNPL and the two-pot retirement system offer new ways to access capital, but they require careful management to be truly effective. To navigate these options successfully, it’s essential to balance short-term access to funds with long-term financial goals.

• BNPL: Budget carefully to avoid late fees and protect your credit score. Limit usage to essential purchases and ensure you can meet repayment obligations without strain.
• Two-Pot System: Withdraw from your savings pot only when necessary. Be mindful of taxes on withdrawals and consider investing the remaining funds to grow your long-term savings.

How Will You Manage Your Capital?

As BNPL and the two-pot system continue to shape personal finance, it’s more important than ever to weigh the risks and rewards of accessing capital. BNPL may offer convenience but can lead to financial pitfalls if not carefully managed. Similarly, the two-pot system provides valuable flexibility, but only if withdrawals are made wisely.

Several challenges must be addressed before withdrawals become widely available to all fund members, and for BNPL to reach broader acceptance, more retailers will need to adopt the payment method. EasyCredit, as a form of credit, also enables investors to use their shares as collateral for a loan, providing access to capital using the shares one owns.

As these financial tools evolve, the question remains: If you had access to more capital, how would you adjust your budget and build an investment portfolio that supports your future income and spending habits?

Avengers Assemble ✊—a saying commonly used among the investor community when there’s news about Aveng, a company that once traded at less than R0.05 due to the deterioration of the South African construction industry.

Last week, the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) kept the repo rate at 8.25% for the seventh consecutive meeting in July 2024, as expected. Two policymakers favoured a 25 basis point cut. 

In the intricate world of finance, money is the lifeblood that fuels economies, shapes markets, and drives innovation. Yet, how much do we truly understand the journey of money from its inception to its role in our daily lives?